LANDMARK DECISION ON THE PRIVATE ENFORCEMENT OF COMPETITION LAW

The Amsterdam District Court issued a landmark decision in the field of private enforcement of Competition Law, awarding damages of €111 million in favour of Macedonian Thrace Brewery against Heineken N.V. and its Greek subsidiary.

We are particularly pleased to announce this decision, given our law firm’s contribution to the proceedings through at least five legal opinions and numerous legal notes at every stage of the case. The first two opinions were conducted in cooperation with Professor Dimitris Liappis.

In particular, our firm contributed to the progression of case law on the private enforcement of Competition Law by providing legal opinions on a number of novel legal issues. At various stages of the proceedings, our views found fertile ground, including the following: (a) That a tortious act giving rise to a claim for damages is established not only when an absolute right of the injured party is infringed, but also when a legally protected private right is adversely affected, or when a duty of care is breached. Such a duty entails the obligation to protect the rights of third parties, particularly when the party causing the damage has, through its conduct, created a business and trading environment capable of causing harm to third parties.  (b) That the determination of the group of entities against which damages claims may be brought is determined by reference to the concept of the “single economic entity”, which departs from the principle under Greek law whereby the person causing the damage and the person liable for its compensation are generally the same person. (c) That, within the meaning of ”single economic entity” as defined above, the attribution of a subsidiary’s conduct to its parent company is not relevant solely to the public enforcement of competition rules, but also to their private enforcement. (d) Also, that, under the same concept of the “single economic entity”, the attribution of a subsidiary’s conduct to its parent company is equally applicable in the context of private enforcement of Competition Law. (e) Finally, that such attribution is justified by the presumed exercise of decisive influence by the parent company over its subsidiary’s business decisions, as reflected not only in close personal relationships but also in the organisational mechanisms through which influence and control are exercised.

In this context, the Court of Justice of the European Union (CJEU) issued a decision of pivotal importance following a preliminary reference submitted by MTB (Case C-393/23), concerning the establishment of jurisdiction of the courts of the Member State in which the parent company is domiciled. More specifically, the CJEU ruled that the courts of the Member State in which the parent company is domiciled may establish international jurisdiction over damages actions brought against both the parent company and its subsidiary for infringements of competition law, relying on the presumption of “decisive influence”.

Finally, thorny and challenging issues arose in relation to both the commencement of the limitation period and the quantification of the damage suffered by MTB, specifically with regard to the point in time from which both the loss (and, in particular, loss of profits) and interest should be calculated. As regards the quantification of damages in particular, as is also evident in the final decision awarding €111 million, a number of novel issues were raised within the European legal order. Namely, the following arguments were advanced:

– The calculation of actual loss and the loss of profits from the commencement of a “single and continuous infringement” of competition rules.

– The determination of the starting point of the limitation period for the damages claim by reference to the cessation of the “single and continuous infringement”.

– The principle of effectiveness under EU law (“effet utile”) displaces conflicting national rules, thereby ensuring full compensation for injured parties and moving beyond the rigid boundaries of national case-law,  concerning loss of profits and statutory interest, allowing both to be awarded cumulatively.

– The application of Greek law, as the substantive law governing the dispute (“lex causae”), rather than Dutch law, as the law of the court before which the proceedings are pending (“lex fori”). Greek law provides for the calculation of default interest on the amount awarded from the date on which the statement of claim seeking compensation is served, while excluding the concurrent award of statutory interest.

ΕΠΙΚΟΙΝΩΝΙΑ

Χρειάζεστε περισσότερες πληροφορίες; Συμπληρώστε την παρακάτω φόρμα. και θα επικοινωνήσουμε μαζί σας το συντομότερο.

Not readable? Change text. captcha txt